Pay out when you need to...
Pay out when you need to...
Of course you're right--there are times when you have to pay to play. This single use didn't seem like one of those times to me, that's all.
I'm a big believer in trying software before you buy so you don't get stuck with a white elephant [or twenty] that you really don't need & can't really use. Especially when you're a student. And it has nothing to do with refusing to accept the realities of business expenses. When you're learning, you try all kinds of things as you figure it out--and a lot of the things you try won't pan out. It's not like they're seasoned pros like you that can distinguish what is valid & legitimate for your workflow & what is really not worthwhile. That's a bit like saying you should just buy the car the experts tell you is best without test-driving it or anything else first.
And in this case, who really cares if the quality is a bit off (and I'm not convinced it has to be)? The idea--IMHO--is to learn the skill, tell the best story you can, then buy the best tool if you decide you need it. As a teacher, would you really dock a student's grade on a creative project just because you felt they could get better output quality with more expensive software? I doubt it--you wouldn't penalize them for not using DigiBeta instead of DV. I also think the exercise of seeking out alternate solutions is a good way to train independent filmmakers who will need creative, inexpensive solutions at every step of their projects & careers. It's good to learn early that money isn't the only--or even the best--way to skin a cat.
And, yes, Mac is a unix kernel. It's not open-source. There's a big difference, as you know. Most folks who would be reading this probably aren't too interested in command-line applications, I'd guess. Yes, there is good open-source, friendly GUI software for Macs (like here:
http://www.opensourcemac.org/). My experience is that there's just nowhere near as much of it as for PCs which stands to reason, given the ratio of users...I can't remember, is it around 20:1 or so now? BTW, I use both PC & Mac. :wink: